Welsh rugby: Andy Howell asks can regions follow Leinster by competing with …

New sponsor, new TV broadcaster, new Europe. new buzz… though a same aged emanate of attendances not assembly a barometer set by David Moffett entirely 11 years ago.

The initial weekend of the Guinness Pro12 saw some scintillating rugby, a bolt of gorgeous tries and fearsome brazen play. Pretty many to a person, a pundits were intemperate in their plaudits.

Yet notwithstanding a hype, that was entirely fit given a movement on a margin of play, one emanate still needs to be resolved. How do a Welsh regions get a open to opinion with their feet by attracting them by a turnstiles?

When a Blues, Ospreys, Scarlets and Dragons were initial shaped in a summer of 2003, afterwards Welsh Rugby Union arch executive Moffett gave them a aim of attracting an normal home embankment of 8,000.

David Moffett set some receptive targets for a regions


Last season, usually a Blues met that figure, averaging 8,212. The Ospreys, Wales’ many successful region, dipped subsequent it for a second debate in a row, a Scarlets crashed, while a Dragons have never been remotely close.

Ironically, they indeed bucked a descending attendances trend by recording their top normal embankment of 6,201 during 2013-14… though that was still approach off Moffett’s mantra.

Lyn Jones’ group accommodate a Ospreys in a initial informal derby compare of a season, though will even that domestic dust-up mangle a 8,000 barrier?

Poor crowds to flog off a season

It’s early days in a new Guinness Pro12, though let’s usually contend a regions will be anticipating a opening weekend doesn’t turn a pointer of a times with regards to home crowds.

The Scarlets were concerned in a 32-32 thriller with Ulster final Saturday and will have been anticipating for some-more than a 6,531 who incited adult in Llanelli.


When we cruise it was a reversion to a good aged days, an out-of-date Saturday afternoon kick-off, with no human TV coverage and dual genuinely-decent sides on show, we do have to ask what some-more do people want?

The Ospreys, who have won a fasten a record 4 times and have so been successful on a pitch, thumped Treviso during a Liberty Stadium on Friday night, though their embankment was usually 6,213.

They have mislaid their Galacticos and there aren’t so many star turns for a open to follow during a Ospreys, though a hierarchy there will know there is copiousness of work to do in sequence to re-engage with a open and, as an comprehensive minimum, accommodate Moffett’s settled target.

The Blues horde Glasgow this weekend in what is potentially a rip-roarer. But what will a throng be for that one?

The money-men will positively be examination with seductiveness and hoping, as a deteriorate progresses, there is an upswing in interest.

So given are a Welsh regions struggling to attract a numbers? Well, there are a horde of reasons.

Watch: Our group plead crowds in Focus on Rugby

Video loading


The sour domestic quarrel between a regions and a WRU, and a exodus of Wales stars like Jamie Roberts, George North, James Hook, Dan Lydiate and Luke Charteris to clubs in France and England, has clearly had an impact.

The credit of a Celtic League, with teams putting out so many second-string players, has adult to now been called into question. Yet this is a contest that has supposing a bulk of Six Nations and European success in new times, not to discuss Lions XV dominance.

Some rugby fans, still unfortunate during a demeanour in that Moffett finished a age-old bar diversion here, simply will not buy into informal rugby. Can they be won over? What work do a regions still need to do in sequence to grasp that?

Cardiff City and Swansea City success

Then we have a unprecedented new success of Cardiff City and Swansea City, any reaching a Premier League and so attracting many of a floating voters.

If you’ve got a choice of Ospreys v Connacht or Swansea contra Manchester United, that one are we going to choose?


Yet rugby is a inhabitant sport, not football. Just demeanour during what happens any time Warren Gatland’s Wales play.

While a informal diversion has struggled in Wales, it’s positively drifting in Ireland, with their large 3 provinces of Leinster, Munster and Ulster thriving.

This is a unusual fact, though Munster and Ulster any drew in some-more fans than a Scarlets and Dragons total final season.

Here’s another unusual fact. Leinster’s normal embankment of 21,081 was usually 43 reduce than that of a Ospreys, Scarlets and Dragons combined.

With a WRU carrying reached agreement with a regions, and a new hum surrounding this season, it’s a watershed impulse in Welsh rugby.

Qualification for Europe will be some-more competitive, with Wales, Ireland, Italy and Scotland any being guaranteed usually one involuntary place. Surely that means full-on matches, fireworks… and bigger crowds.




The Blues reason a best normal home assemblage of a informal era, 15,108, when they reached a semi-final of Europe’s Heineken Cup in 2008-09.

That figure includes matches staged opposite Gloucester and Toulouse during a Millennium Stadium, though not a 40,000-plus who attended a semi-final with Leicester, given it was classed as a “neutral” venue.

That year, David Young’s group ran amok opposite Gloucester in a Anglo-Welsh Cup final during English rugby’s Twickenham domicile and kick Jonny Wilkinson’s star-studded Toulon to lift Europe’s second-tier Amlin Challenge Cup a following campaign.

But relocating to Cardiff City Stadium backfired and they changed behind to a Arms Park on a permanent basement dual years ago.

Crowds rose during Phil Davies’ initial deteriorate as coach, their normal embankment going adult from 7,261 in 2011-12 to 8,397 a following deteriorate before dipping to 8,212 final reign – still some-more than a 2002-03 deteriorate when Cardiff, as a bar side, drew a 7,000 normal home attendance.

Last season’s dump came on a behind of bad results, with a miss of success costing Davies his pursuit before a finish of a campaign.

With former New Zealand harlot Mark Hammett, who was manager of a Wellington-based Hurricanes Super 15 team, now in assign and a bolt of high-quality signings, that embody Adam Jones and a Waikato-based Chiefs star Gareth Anscombe, many is approaching of a Blues this time around.


Since finishing a warn third in a initial fasten debate of 2003-04, underneath a shrewd superintendence of Mike Ruddock, and fourth a following season, they have finished subsequent to zero given reaching a semi-final of a Amlin Challenge Cup 7 years ago.

The Dragons never got to a knockout theatre of a Heineken Cup and subsequent reign are again in Europe’s new second-tier contest – a Blues fasten them underneath a restructure that has taken place – for a fifth debate given entrance into existence.

Nevertheless, they have bucked a trend over a final dual seasons, with their normal embankment carrying damaged a 6,000 separator for a initial time as it has left adult to 6,201 in all competitions – Europe, Pro12 and Anglo-Welsh.

That figure is aloft than a 6,120 normal claimed by Newport during a final deteriorate of veteran bar rugby in 2002-03.

Having a maverick, though respected, Lyn Jones, who has been Wales’ many successful manager of a informal epoch with 3 trophies during his time during a Ospreys, and Kingsley Jones during a helm has helped them enormously, notwithstanding formula dropping off as final deteriorate went on.

The signings of former Wales and Lions full-back Lee Byrne, Ian Gough, Aled Brew, Stormers Super 15 column Brok Harris and a bolt of others, has increasing Dragons’ strength in depth.

With a new state of a art training bottom during Ystrad Mynach and carrying played a accessible opposite English champions Northampton Saints during Ebbw Vale, there’s a clarity they are finally prepared to welcome all of Gwent.

There could be a swell of goodwill towards them during a start of a debate and, if formula follow, attendances could stand serve from a 5,288 a Dragons managed in a initial deteriorate underneath Ruddock’s tenure.



They have been Wales’ many successful region, lifting a Pro12 pretension a record 4 times, demolishing Leicester during Twickenham when a Anglo-Welsh Cup was contested by full-strength teams and providing a core of a Wales group that has won 3 Grand Slams and reached a World Cup semi-final.

Their best normal embankment was 10,227 in 2008-09, entrance on a behind of a fasten title, a European quarter-final and braggadocio some of a world’s many apparent rugby faces, with Shane Williams, Justin Marshall, Jerry Collins, James Hook, Gavin Henson, Ryan Jones, Adam Jones and Tommy Bowe among those who have been on their books.

The Ospreys had an normal embankment of 8,910 during a 2012-13 campaign, entrance on a behind of a pretentious Pro12 final delight over afterwards Heineken kings Leinster in Dublin, and an unusual value-for-money season-ticket deal.

But they have given unsuccessful to validate for a fasten play-offs or a knock-out theatre in Europe and their normal embankment dipped final deteriorate to 7,706.

More big-name departures have occurred, with Adam Jones carrying assimilated a Blues, Richard Hibbard withdrawal for Gloucester, and Ryan Jones and Matthew Morgan going to Bristol, lifting concerns about their competitiveness.

That said, their normal is improved than a total Neath (4,594) and Swansea (2,775) total in a final year of bar rugby.


The Scarlets won a initial Celtic League in 2003-04, were a initial segment to strech an Anglo-Welsh final, losing during London Wasps, and a initial to post an normal embankment in additional of 9,000.

They were Wales’ best-supported group in 2011-12, with an normal of 9,655.

But they forsaken to 7,772 in 2012-13 notwithstanding being a usually group from Wales to strech a Pro12 play-offs.

On a behind of what was a successful campaign, we would have approaching their attendances to have possibly left adult or hold organisation final season, though they fell to 7,217.

They lacked coherence on a pitch, with dual peppery matches opposite English large guns Harlequins in Europe being overshadowed by a series of common performances.

It’s hoped a attainment of New Zealander Wayne Pivac, who has coached Fiji, as inheritor to Ireland-bound Simon Easterby competence have a certain effect.


There’s a new brush unconditional Welsh rugby, with a Blues and Scarlets carrying new conduct coaches in Kiwis Hammett and Pivac and new aptness regimes in place opposite a board.

That’s expected to outcome in a some-more sparkling and faster Super 15 character of rugby given we can’t censor from a fact there’s been some dour, conservative, unambitious and uninspiring transport from Welsh member in a Pro12.

Hopefully, a shoots of liberation will grow this deteriorate with a subsequent step for a WRU and a regions being a accordant bid to move a Welsh exiles home.

When we demeanour behind during past attendances in Wales, and a multiplying of a Irish, a thing that is glaringly apparent is that large crowds come on a behind of on-field success.

That’s given Leinster’s normal home embankment in competitions rose to 20,782 in 2012-13 and 21,081 final season.

Their figure of 28,137 in Europe final reign is aloft than a series of Premier League football sides, including Swansea City.

Moffett’s 8,000 benchmark for a regions is approach subsequent that.


Can a 4 strech a aim this season? Discuss Andy’s commentary with us on Facebook

Article source: http://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/rugby/rugby-news/welsh-rugby-crowds-andy-howell-7754853

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.